key takeaway
More than 6 in 10 households in California earning less than $35,000 had difficulty paying for basic expenses from March to mid-July of 2023.
Despite the critical role that child care plays in children’s healthy development and families’ economic security, child care in California remains unaffordable for the majority of families that need it. These affordability challenges reflect that child care is a “broken market.” In other words, the resources required to provide enriching and nourishing care to children — including provider salaries, food, materials, transportation, and other critical costs — is much higher than what most families can afford to pay. As a result, families (particularly families with low incomes) face unaffordable child care costs even as child care providers remain severely underpaid. Addressing this market failure requires substantial public investment.
Until then, as highlighted throughout this brief, families with young children across the state will continue to face burdensomely high child care costs. Specifically, this brief shows the child care costs that families face with an infant and a school-age child in eight California counties. These examples illustrate that families across geographies and jobs cannot reasonably afford child care without more public investment.
Households Face Child Care Affordability Challenges Across California
Calculating child care affordability” is complex and nuanced; however, recent federal actions provide a direction for how to understand child care affordability for families. In 2024, the Biden Administration limited family fees for families enrolled in publicly funded child care to 7% of a family’s income (family fees in California are capped at 1%). While the Trump Administration has since revoked this policy, the Biden-era policy states that payment above 7% of a family’s income is “an impermissible barrier to child care access.” In California, an estimated 7 in 10 families with a need for child care would pay more than 7% of their family income based on the median cost of care for their children.1Budget Center’s analysis of California Department of Education, 2021 Regional Market Rate Survey and US Census Bureau, 2024 American Community Survey public-use microdata downloaded from IPUMS USA (University of Minnesota, www.ipums.org). The cost of child care for an infant and school-age child was calculated using the 2021 Regional Market Rate Survey adjusted for inflation using the Bureau of Labor Statistics CPI-U day care and preschool series (not seasonally adjusted). Median full-time rates were used when all available parents typically worked more than 25 hours in a week. Median part-time rates were used if at least one parent worked 25 or fewer hours in a week. Child care costs for full-time school-age care were prorated to account for school schedules.
To gain a richer picture of what this strain looks like for households across California, the following analyses identified common professions in California — among families that do and do not qualify for publicly funded child care — and outlined exactly what it would take to afford child care at 7% of their income.2As explained by the Bipartisan Policy Center, using a single metric for child care affordability has limitations. This analysis utilizes 7% as an affordability benchmark to illustrate the high cost of care across the state, but this benchmark may not be appropriate in all cases. The results paint a picture of the unreasonable child care cost demands that a diversity of California families face.
- Packager and Agricultural Worker in Fresno County
- Construction Laborer and Janitor/Building Cleaner in Humboldt County
- Police Officer and Registered Nurse in Los Angeles County
- Cashier and Personal Care Aide in Marin County
- Retail Sales Manager and Customer Service Representative in Sacramento County
- Maid/Housekeeper and Landscaper/Groundskeeper in San Bernardino County
- Office Clerk and Sales Truck Driver in San Diego County
- Software Developer and Financial Manager in San Mateo County
Implications
Regardless of location or occupation, child care is unaffordable for the vast majority of California families. The high cost of care — driven by necessary expenses like wages, facility costs, and materials — creates a “broken market” where families cannot afford child care and providers are often underpaid.
When families can’t secure affordable child care, it affects children’s healthy development and families’ economic stability. This disproportionately impacts families with low incomes who are already struggling to make ends meet. What’s more, family economic security has only gotten worse due to President Trump’s war in Iran, which has increased household expenses for all Californians, as well as congressional Republicans’ harmful cuts to health care and food assistance, with more cuts taking effect in the coming months.
The child care system works only for a wealthy few, not for everyday families or the providers that offer care. Addressing the failures in the child care system will require action on the part of state and federal policymakers, such as:
- Expanding the number of publicly funded child care spaces. Publicly funded child care provides low- or no-cost care for families with low incomes and/or families who meet need-based qualifications. Because of limited state and federal dollars, only 1 in 6 California children eligible for publicly funded child care are enrolled in programs administered by the California Department of Social Services. Increasing state and federal dollars for publicly funded child care would expand families’ access to safe, affordable care while freeing up thousands of dollars a year for other household expenses.
- Providing fair and equitable pay for child care providers. California has committed to changing the way the state pays child care providers that offer publicly funded child care. This commitment includes developing a new single rate structure to pay child care providers based on the estimated cost of care, rather than what families can afford to pay. The state began this process in 2023 but has not yet completed the initial steps needed for a successful transition to a new rate structure. As the administration moves forward with the rate reform process (including a new team of cost model consultants), they must develop the new rate structure in a timely fashion that reimburses providers based on the real-world costs of providing care.
Ultimately, policymakers should acknowledge that child care is a public good that benefits children, families, communities, and the economy. This would mean expanding access to affordable and nurturing child care for all families who are priced out of the system and fairly compensating the child care providers for their vital work. Until then, California families will continue to struggle to afford the high cost of care.
